
By Bruce Holley and Greg Parets, Managing Directors, Alvarez & Marsal (A&M)
As banks head into 2026 and evaluate where to spend time and capital, one question keeps resurfacing: Does scale actually matter for efficiency? Our research across approximately 50 US banks makes the answer clear: Scale, spending and footprint don’t separate leaders from laggards; execution does. If you’re determining priorities for the year ahead, efficiency isn’t about what you have; it’s about how well you run it.
What drives bank efficiency? Does scale matter?
For decades, conventional wisdom claimed that “bigger is better” and scale drives efficiency. Banks pursued mergers and acquisitions (M&As), expanded balance sheets and built sprawling branch networks, all in the name of lowering costs. But our benchmark of around 50 US banks proves otherwise: Scale, technology budgets and footprint don’t explain who wins and who lags. Leaders and laggards appear at every size and spending level.
What truly separates top performers is a strong management team that focuses on a well-articulated operating model that’s closely aligned with customer-led execution—converting dollars into outcomes with speed, accountability and continual reinvention. Those that get it right pull ahead. Those that don’t fall behind. Efficiency isn’t about inputs; it’s about execution. And banks that keep chasing the wrong levers will keep spending more to get less.
We benchmarked approximately (~) 50 US banks across asset tiers using public filings (10-Ks and 10-Qs filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission [SEC]), investor presentations and S&P Capital IQ to analyze efficiency ratios, operating leverage, branch density, fee-income mix and technology spend. The statistical lift from these inputs was negligible (R2 values near zero), so we focused the paper on what actually differentiates outcomes.
Scale: No significant correlation with efficiency.
Our analysis found no significant correlation between asset size and efficiency ratio. Institutions in our study ranged from ~$50 billion to more than $4 trillion in assets, yet both low- and high-performing banks appeared in every size tier. This finding challenges the long-held assumption that larger balance sheets inherently translate into lower costs. In fact, unchecked growth without disciplined integration and operating leverage can magnify inefficiency by adding complexity faster than scale can absorb it.
Implications: Scale is a potential enabler of efficiency, not a guarantee. Without deliberate operating-model alignment and rigorous capital discipline, growth can erode rather than enhance performance. Institutions must focus on how they deploy scale—leveraging it to consolidate platforms, simplify processes and expand margins—rather than allowing size to entrench inefficiency.
Operating leverage: No link to efficiency, but it can act as an early warning.
More than half of the banks we benchmarked experienced negative operating leverage—meaning their expenses grew faster than their revenues. This is not a marginal effect; it’s a structural warning sign that the cost base is expanding without the revenue to support it. In a rising-cost environment, such imbalances compound quickly, pressuring margins and eroding shareholder value.
Implications: While operating leverage doesn’t appear to correlate with today’s efficiency, it’s clearly a leading indicator of long-term structural health. Positive leverage reflects a model that can grow without proportionally increasing costs; negative leverage often points to deep-rooted inefficiencies. Banks must diagnose and address the sources of cost rigidity early, before they compound into sustained margin erosion.
Branch networks: Size doesn’t equal savings.
Branch density has long been debated as a driver of efficiency, and our findings show only a weak and inconsistent relationship. While quartile averages reveal a directional tendency—banks with higher branch density tend to post higher (worse) efficiency ratios—the overall statistical correlation is statistically near zero (R2 ≈ 0.08). Across our dataset, branch density ranged from fewer than 10 to more than 85 branches per $10 billion in assets, yet efficiency ratios often differed by more than 25 percentage points within similar density bands.
Implications: While higher branch density can certainly contribute to lower efficiency, and footprint rationalization can clearly deliver savings, the impact is muted if it is not part of a broader operating-model strategy. Paired with back-office modernization, digital adoption and service-model redesign, branch-office optimization can meaningfully contribute to efficiency. Because banks with similar branch density can operate within vastly different cost structures, it’s clear that execution, not network size, is the decisive factor.
Fee income: Varies widely; prioritize quality over quantity.
Fee income has been a popular target for tackling efficiency, especially as net interest margins (NIMs) remain volatile. Although higher shares of noninterest income are correlated with better efficiency ratios, the quality and scalability of that income matter just as much as the headline percentage. This distinction is more urgent in the current macroclimate. Banks face interest income compression on multiple fronts: volatile Federal Reserve policy, tariff-driven inflation and rising delinquencies in core loan portfolios, such as commercial real estate (CRE) and credit cards. Many institutions have already revised their 2025 net investment income (NII) guidance downward due to loan-growth pressures and refinancing risks, raising the stakes for fee-based earnings resilience.
Implications: Fee income is not just a diversification tool; it is a necessity for earnings resilience in an environment of compressed interest margins. Banks that can grow high-quality, recurring fee streams while delivering them through leaner operating models will be better positioned to maintain margins and stability regardless of rate cycles or credit conditions.
Technology spending: Fails to explain efficiency, but discipline does drive returns.
Banks that spend more on technology are not reliably more efficient. Top-quartile banks allocate a meaningfully higher share of noninterest expense to tech than bottom-quartile peers, but the spread does not, on its own, translate into a strong statistical relationship with efficiency. What matters is how the spend is sequenced, governed and adopted—where dollars fund scalable platform simplification, automation and measurable unit-cost reduction rather than diffuse “innovation”.
Implications: Efficiency isn’t about spending more or less; it’s about spending with intent and holding teams accountable for the impact. Leaders know where to invest, when to invest and why. Laggards treat spending as an activity; leaders turn it into an advantage.
What drives efficiency: Defining the right operating model and executing it flawlessly.
Debates about size, tech budgets or footprints miss the point. Our ~50-bank benchmark shows that leaders win by turning dollars into outcomes—fast, visibly and repeatably—while avoiding the traps that drain value: unchecked growth that adds complexity, negative operating leverage, legacy-heavy footprints, episodic (non-scalable) fee income and unfocused tech spend. Efficiency is not an input story; it’s an execution system built on clear accountability, faster decisions, relentless customer focus and continuous reinvention.
What comes next: Your 12-to-18-month efficiency playbook
- Diagnose operating leverage: Identify where expenses are growing faster than revenue; set quarterly targets to reverse the trend; and tie leadership incentives to the spread.
- Fund only what lowers unit costs: Re-sequence tech programs so that 80 percent of the spend is tied to measurable unit-cost reductions or time-to-serve; stop or pause the rest.
- Shift the earnings mix: Tilt toward recurring, scalable fee streams (treasury, trust/wealth); set product-level hurdle rates; and prune episodic, high-touch lines.
- Rationalize legacy and footprint: Consolidate platforms; deprecate custom one-offs; and right-size branches using customer-journey volumes and utilization—not anecdotes.
- Install an execution office: One owner, transparent key performance indicators (KPIs) (efficiency ratio, operating leverage, unit costs, digital adoption), monthly course corrections and published benefits tracking.
Banks that institutionalize this operating cadence will compound efficiency and resilience. Those that don’t will keep spending more to get less—and fall behind. Alvarez & Marsal’s (A&M’s) deep industry expertise and hands-on delivery can turn investments into outcomes and ambitions into results.
