By Byron Loflin, VP, Global Head of Board Advisory, Nasdaq
Trust is presently on the decline in many areas of our world. In the intricate sphere of public-company management, confidence and accountability are two pillars that underpin sustainable success. Nowhere is this dynamic more crucial than in banking, in which trust and transparency dictate relationships with stakeholders and drive key performance metrics, including total shareholder return (TSR) and talent retention.
During the past 15 years, I have interviewed roughly 1,000 board members and chief executive officers (CEOs) on the topic of board effectiveness. This article explores the importance of confidence and accountability, their interplay within board and management leadership, and the broader implications of a bank’s stakeholder relationships with a focus on business sustainability, talent retention and TSR.
The 25th Annual Edelman Trust Barometer Report, released on January 21, 2025, in Davos, Switzerland (World Economic Forum’s annual meeting), highlights some concerning trends in trust, further emphasizing the need for the qualities of confidence and accountability. Looking across 28 countries, Edelman found again that Business was the only institution clearly considered both ethical and competent, with Government and Media continuing to be seen as neither. In fact, Business saw a 19-point increase in its net ethical score, from -2 to +17 since 2020—a huge jump (Page 24). This should not prompt complacency among directors.
Within its report, Edelman subtly emphasized trustworthiness as both an opportunity and an advantage for businesses. While the report did not specifically break out banking from other business sectors, financial services experienced a two-point improvement over 2024 (Page 47).
Confidence: a foundation for success
Confidence reinforces public trust and stakeholder faith in a company’s ability to deliver on promises, achieve growth and maintain stability. For banks, as custodians of public funds, this confidence is indispensable. Customers, investors and other stakeholders trust banks to safeguard deposits, deliver predictable returns and maintain systemic stability.
Confidence in a public company arises from several factors:
- Strong leadership: Leadership integrity, vision and decisiveness inspire confidence in the board and management.
- Transparent communication: Clear, honest and timely communication about challenges, opportunities and strategic direction fosters trust.
- Consistent performance: Delivering on financial targets, such as earnings growth and return on equity (ROE), reassures investors and other stakeholders.
In banking, confidence has ripple effects across the industry. The 2008 financial crisis, for instance, demonstrated how quickly a loss of confidence in one institution can destabilize the entire system, resulting in widespread business failures. Banks must, therefore, ensure that their management teams and boards consistently exhibit competence and reliability.
Accountability: the balancing force
While confidence drives trust and positive sentiment, accountability ensures actions align with expectations. Accountability in public-company management refers to leaders’ obligation to act transparently, answer for their decisions and remain aligned with stakeholders’ interests. For boards and management teams, accountability involves balancing short-term goals, such as quarterly earnings, with long-term objectives, such as sustainable growth and risk management.
Mechanisms of accountability
Accountability in public companies is reinforced through:
- Corporate governance: Boards of directors oversee corporate vision and strategy, ensure effective leadership and provide stewardship continuity over the long term.
- Stakeholder engagement: Reliability of communication with employees, investors and other stakeholders holds leadership accountable for both messaging and actions.
- Smart regulatory oversight: The banking regulatory system is designed to ensure compliance with laws, safeguard customer interests and mitigate systemic risks. It’s important that improvements to the system remain dynamic and forward-looking.
Accountability is essential for maintaining trust, particularly when leadership decisions have far-reaching consequences. For example, when a bank faces a cyberattack or a non-systemic financial scandal, transparent disclosures and corrective actions signal accountability and help rebuild stakeholder trust.
The interplay between confidence and accountability
Confidence and accountability are inherently interconnected. Confidence without accountability risks complacency, mismanagement or ethical lapses. Conversely, accountability without confidence may result in micromanagement, stagnation or mistrust. Effective public-company leadership requires striking a balance whereby confidence enables strengthened accountability, and accountability reinforces an exchange of confidence between the board and management.
Case study: restoring trust through accountability
The banking scandals of the past 25 years illustrate the dynamic interplay of confidence and accountability. Whether the financial crisis of 2008 or lesser events over the past 20 years, when a scandal broke, customer and investor confidence plummeted. Accountability measures after a material governance deficiency often include executive resignations, board restructuring, operational overhauls or the forced sale of a deficient bank to a more secure and well-governed institution to restore trust. These actions signal the regulatory and banking systems’ commitments to rectify mistakes and rebuild stakeholder confidence.
Impacts on key stakeholders
- Customers and regulators
In banking, confidence and accountability directly affect relationships with customers and regulators. Customers expect banks to manage their funds prudently and provide reliable services. Accountability mechanisms, such as compliance with anti-money laundering (AML) regulations, reinforce confidence by ensuring ethical behavior and operational integrity. For regulators, transparent reporting and adherence to capital-adequacy standards reflect accountability, promoting stability within the financial system.
- Shareholders and total shareholder return
Confidence and accountability significantly impact total shareholder return (TSR), a key metric for assessing a public company’s financial performance. TSR is one of the primary metrics for comparing performance across a sector and an indicator of long-term business or bank sustainability.
- Confidence drives investment: Confident investors are more likely to buy and hold shares, boosting demand and share prices. When a bank’s leadership articulates a clear vision and delivers consistent results, shareholder confidence rises, positively influencing TSR.
- Accountability mitigates risks: Accountability ensures responsible decision-making and adherence to governance standards, reducing the likelihood of scandals, fines or operational disruptions that could erode shareholder value.
A failure in either domain can have devastating effects on TSR. For instance, the collapse of Lehman Brothers in 2008 was driven by a loss of confidence in the bank’s solvency, compounded by accountability failures in risk management and governance.
- Employees: attraction and retention
A bank’s ability to attract and retain top talent hinges on its reputation, which is shaped by confidence and accountability. Employees seek to work for institutions with strong leadership, ethical practices and growth opportunities. When management demonstrates confidence in its strategic direction and accountability for its decisions, it fosters a culture of trust and engagement.
- Confidence inspires loyalty: Employees are more likely to remain with a company that exhibits stable and visionary leadership. Confidence in the company’s future translates into confidence in one’s own career trajectory. When leadership frequently alters strategy, leadership structure and marketing taglines and then poorly messages these changes, employees become nervous.
- Accountability builds fairness: Transparent and accountable leadership creates a sense of fairness and inclusivity, which is critical for retaining diverse talent. When employees perceive merit accountability in decisions related to promotions, pay fairness or performance reviews, they are more likely to feel valued and committed.
Enhancing relationships with key stakeholders
The relationship between a bank and its stakeholders thrives when confidence and accountability are in harmony. This balance fosters trust, strengthens loyalty and drives sustainable success.
- Confidence and accountability as a feedback loop
Confidence and accountability often reinforce each other in a virtuous cycle. For example:
- Transparent communication (accountability) enhances confidence by providing stakeholders with the information needed to trust leadership decisions.
- Strong performance (confidence) bolsters accountability by creating a track record of reliability, reducing the need for intrusive oversight.
- Mitigating risks
The absence of either factor can undermine stakeholder relationships. Overconfidence without accountability can lead to excessive risk-taking, as seen in the 2008 financial crisis. Conversely, excessive accountability without confidence can result in risk aversion, stifling innovation and growth. By balancing these elements, banks can navigate uncertainties while maintaining stakeholder trust.
- Adapting to change
The financial industry is evolving rapidly due to technological advancements, regulatory changes and shifting customer expectations. Confidence in leadership’s ability to adapt, coupled with accountability for navigating these transitions responsibly, is critical for maintaining stakeholder relationships.
- A practical approach to board and management confidence and accountability
Board meetings typically occur four to eight times per year and are vital opportunities for board and management interactions. Since all power within the corporation ultimately rests with the board, each meeting either bolsters or weakens confidence. The board will gain meaningful insights if it asks management, “After your presentation to the board, did you depart with more or less confidence? And did the board’s reception to and interaction with your presentation cause more or less confidence in its leadership?”
Recommendations for leadership
To manage the interplay of confidence and accountability effectively, public-company managers and boards should adopt the following strategies:
- Promote transparency: Regularly communicate with stakeholders about challenges, achievements and strategic priorities. Transparency fosters both confidence and accountability. The more effectively boards communicate, the more confident management should feel that they can communicate both successes and failures candidly.
- Foster a culture of accountability: Establish clear governance structures, ethical guidelines and performance metrics to hold leadership accountable at all levels. Conduct board performance reviews that include input from management.
- Invest in leadership development: Cultivate leaders who inspire confidence through competence and maintain accountability through integrity.
- Engage stakeholders proactively: Actively seek feedback from customers, employees and shareholders to ensure alignment with their expectations and concerns.
- Balance short- and long-term goals: While recognizing the business responsibility to perform on a quarterly basis, ensure that decisions are made with a view toward long-term strategy and business sustainability.
Conclusion
Confidence and accountability are indispensable for effective leadership in public-company management and board governance, particularly in the banking sector. Confidence inspires trust and loyalty among stakeholders, while accountability ensures actions align with ethical standards and stakeholder interests. Together, these factors create a robust foundation for achieving key objectives, such as strong TSR and employee retention.
By balancing confidence and accountability, banks can strengthen relationships with customers, investors, regulators and employees, ensuring sustained success in an increasingly dynamic and competitive environment. Leaders who master this interplay not only safeguard their institutions but also contribute to the stability and resilience of the broader financial system. As stewards of a banking institution, board members play an essential role in the interplay of confidence and accountability.
Along with speaking on and teaching corporate governance effectiveness, Byron holds a BA from James Madison University and has completed the OPM program at Harvard Business School, along with several HBS Executive Education Certificates, including Harvard’s Board Effectiveness program.
