By Shashank Pattekar, International Banker
On October 2, the European Commission (EC) announced that it would propose to extend the phasing in of key EU Deforestation Regulations (EUDRs), initially slated to come into force by the end of this year, by 12 months. This likely extension has allayed coffee producers’ concerns that their access to the European Union (EU) market would be blocked for the time being. In response, coffee prices in recent weeks have fallen from 13-year highs. Does this mean that coffee lovers can look forward to paying progressively less for their morning brews over the coming months?
Coffee prices have been on a strong upward march since late September 2023, with the Arabica futures contract—the global benchmark contract on the Intercontinental Exchange (ICE)—reaching levels not seen since August 2011. The $2.75 per pound recorded on September 26, 2024, was 46 percent higher than at the start of the year and a whopping 91 percent higher than 12 months earlier.
Extreme weather across the world’s biggest coffee-producing nations—Brazil and Vietnam, which together account for around half of global production—did much to push prices higher during this time. Between May 2024 and August 2024, moreover, natural-disaster-monitoring organisation Cemaden (Centro Nacional de Monitoramento e Alertas de Desastres Naturais) found that several important agricultural areas in Brazil had experienced the driest weather conditions since 1981.
The Brazilian state of Minas Gerais—home to around 30 percent of the nation’s Arabica crop—received 235 percent more rain than average in March, according to Kanica Goel, senior analyst at business-intelligence specialist The Smart Cube. “Then in April it received no rainfall, and this has carried on into May and is damaging coffee crops in the country,” Goel told the food publication Food and Drink Digital back in May. Thanks mostly to the hugely powerful weather phenomenon La Niña, the lack of rainfall severely raised the risks for global coffee supplies, with many even claiming it was the worst drought for coffee production ever observed in the country.
Brazil provides more than one-third of the world’s coffee supply and is the chief source of the sweet Arabica bean, which itself accounts for around 75 percent of the world’s coffee production. The more bitter Robusta bean, meanwhile, constitutes the remaining quarter of global coffee production, with Vietnam as its main producer, followed by Indonesia. Similarly, the droughts experienced in Vietnam earlier this year also severely curtailed coffee production in the Southeast Asian country. In late March, Vietnam’s agriculture department stated that Vietnam’s coffee production for the 2023-24 crop season had declined by a mighty 20 percent due to the drought, resulting in the smallest harvest in at least four years.
The summer months then saw an excruciating heatwave engulf the region, with parts of Vietnam experiencing temperatures reaching mid-40 degrees Celsius. More recently, Typhoon Yagi ripped through many key coffee-producing areas in Vietnam and destroyed massive numbers of coffee trees, while there have also been growing expectations that rainfall from La Niña could widely inflict the diseases that affect coffee trees, such as coffee leaf rust. All this extreme weather prompted the General Department of Vietnam Customs to report a 9.9-percent annual decline in Vietnam’s coffee exports for August and a 12.1-percent drop in exports for the January-August period.
It should perhaps be unsurprising that such extreme dryness across the world’s two major coffee producers and exporters has resulted in prices surging to 13-year highs, dramatically raising coffee costs for consumers across the world. “There are several factors contributing to the rising cost of coffee beans. First is the havoc wreaked by extreme weather on key supply markets such as Brazil and Vietnam,” Professor Vinh Thai, logistics and supply chain management at the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology (RMIT) University, observed on August 22. “The continuing increase in container shipping rates and other supply chain issues, by which the lion’s share of coffee bean shipments are transported, also greatly contribute to the cost of coffee. Roasters may need to pass these costs onto cafes who, in turn, may do the same to customers. This will likely add further pressure and negatively affect the lifestyle of customers who are already dealing with the cost of living.”
To compound matters further, higher shipping costs have only added to the bullish price sentiment this year. With the escalating war in Western Asia causing ships in the Red Sea to redirect their routes around the southern tip of South Africa to avoid being potentially attacked, significant delays and surging shipping costs (such as spot freight rates) have also contributed to inflated coffee prices.
With the market also pricing in the strong likelihood that the EU Deforestation Regulation would come into effect by the end of 2024, prices remained buoyant during the first nine months of the year. As the new law would ban the importation of commodities linked to deforestation, coffee producers feared that their exports would be cut off from the EU market. Not only did this greatly raise supply-chain risks, but it also boosted demand from those seeking to capitalise on current market prices before the legislation came into effect. “A lot of players are buying coffee a little bit earlier,” Giuseppe Lavazza, chair of Lavazza Group, which owns coffee giant Lavazza, explained to Bloomberg in early July in reference to the EUDR. “No doubt that the coffee that European roasters are going to buy will cost much more. Companies in the coffee industry are facing very strong headwinds.”
All that said, however, the first half of October saw prices decisively reverse course, with the Arabica contract dropping to below $2.50 per pound by October 7. Much of this decline can be attributed to the European Commission’s October 2 announcement that it would propose to delay the implementation of the EUDR by one year on the grounds that it could be deemed a protectionist move that might exclude millions of poor, small-scale farmers from the EU market.
“Given the EU Deforestation Regulation’s (EUDR) novel character, the swift calendar, and the variety of international stakeholders involved, the Commission considers that a 12-month additional time to phase in the system is a balanced solution to support operators around the world in securing a smooth implementation from the start,” the EC confirmed on October 2, adding that the extension proposal will not put into question the objectives or the substance of the law. “With this step, the Commission aims to provide certainty about the way forward and to ensure the success of the EUDR, which is paramount to address the EU’s contribution to the pressing global issue of deforestation.”
The sell-off can also be partly explained by a series of more bearish announcements in recent months, such as increasingly positive crop-production news from across the world. The International Coffee Organization (ICO) reported on October 8 that global coffee exports rose by 9.2 percent, while exports in the first 11 months of the coffee year 2023-24 (October 2023 to August 2024) increased by 10.4 percent.
Much of this rebound in supply can be credited to Brazil. On August 7, for instance, the Brazilian trade ministry confirmed that coffee exports in July had risen by an annual rate of 44 percent. This followed a July 7 report from the Brazil-based coffee-producer cooperative, Cecafé (Brazilian Coffee Exporters Council), that Brazil’s coffee exports for the 2023-24 crop year had grown by 33 percent. On September 10, Cecafé also noted that green coffee exports in August had risen by 1.4 percent annually. More recently, showers have been observed more frequently, helping to improve the moisture in soils within Brazil’s key coffee-growing regions as well as the flowering process of coffee trees, raising the crop outlook for the world’s biggest coffee producer.
However, supply shortages remain a concern in both Brazil and Vietnam at this stage and should maintain bullish pressure on coffee prices. On September 19, Brazil’s crop-forecasting agency, Conab (Companhia Nacional de Abastecimento), lowered its coffee-production forecast for 2024 for the country from the 58.8 million bags projected in May to 54.8 million bags.
“Coffee prices are not going to go down; [they’re] going to stay very high. The coffee supply chain is dramatically under pressure,” Giuseppe Lavazza told the Financial Times in July, prior to the European Commission’s announced proposal of the EUDR postponement. And with a delay of just one year in the offing for the deforestation legislation, a further rally in coffee prices is not out of the question.
Indeed, climate change represents a long-term structural challenge for the global coffee market—and one that might well keep coffee prices distinctly elevated for some time yet. According to Charles Hart, a senior agribusiness commodities analyst at Fitch Solutions’ BMI, climate change represents “a systemic risk to the coffee sector that will become more acute over the next decade”. Speaking to Nikkei Asia on August 19, Hart said he expected that more extreme weather events could “serve to increase inter-seasonal variation in world coffee production and, thus, see price volatility increase”.
According to the non-profit agricultural-research organisation World Coffee Research (WCR), moreover, the world may face a Robusta-coffee shortage of up to 35 million 60-kilogram bags by 2040, with Vietnamese producers fearing that climate change could drastically reduce available commercial farmland in the country over the coming decades. “I just [went] to a conference in Vietnam. They reported to me that by 2050, the robusta coffee area could be reduced by up to 50 per cent, due to climate change,” An Nguyen, the co-founder and chief executive officer of Helena Coffee (a coffee-processing and export company based in Lam Dong province in Vietnam’s central highland region), acknowledged to Australian state broadcaster ABC (Australian Broadcasting Corporation).
