Home FinanceLifting the Veil: Identifying Ultimate Beneficial Owners

Lifting the Veil: Identifying Ultimate Beneficial Owners

by internationalbanker

By Ted Datta, Senior Director, Financial Crime Industry Practice, Moody’s

 

 

 

 

How can you be sure with whom you’re doing business? In today’s interconnected business landscape, transparency is crucial. An Ultimate Beneficial Owner (UBO) is an entity that controls and influences a company. While the majority of beneficial owners are legitimate and trustworthy, UBOs can also be hidden players in a business network. Those UBOs who obfuscate their business interests may be doing so to conceal their involvements in crimes such as money laundering, human trafficking and fraud.

Illicit actors often exploit complex ownership structures to conceal their identities. While hidden, they can integrate their funds into financial investments, luxury assets and commercial ventures, concealing their engagements in illegal activities.

Regulations involving the identification of UBOs are constantly evolving, both to combat financial crimes and to protect the privacy of beneficial owners. The regulatory landscape is, therefore, increasingly complex and can be resource-intensive to navigate.

Practical implications for navigating regulations

Efforts to combat money laundering and financial crimes have prompted a wave of increasingly stringent regulations for businesses worldwide. An integral part of this push is the Financial Action Task Force’s (FATF’s) amendment to its Recommendation 24 on Beneficial Ownership.

In line with regulations, nations must ensure that companies maintain accurate, up-to-date information on their beneficial owners. Additionally, they must implement measures to verify beneficial ownership by using supplementary information from regulated financial institutions, professionals and stock exchanges.

The European Union (EU) took a similar step with its sixth Anti-Money Laundering Directive, which introduced tougher penalties for non-compliance in new areas such as cybercrime and environmental offenses. Furthermore, the new regulation mandates that companies operating within EU member states must now maintain precise and current information on their beneficial owners.

Adding to the complexity, the directive redefines the identification process for beneficial owners, particularly in cases of indirect shareholding. In line with the EU’s new rulebook, when individuals own shares through multiple entities, these must be added up to determine if they are beneficial owners. Furthermore, the regulations permit member states the flexibility to lower the threshold for beneficial-ownership identification to 15 percent, compared to the standard 25 percent, when dealing with high-risk cases.

These regulatory changes reflect the global trend towards greater financial transparency, which demands increasingly robust due-diligence measures. As governments and international bodies tighten compliance requirements, businesses must adapt or face the financial and reputational penalties of poor risk management.

Lack of uniformity

Alongside regional regulations, firms operating across jurisdictions are challenged with meeting multiple sets of compliance requirements. This lack of standardisation is a significant obstacle for firms that must comply with different thresholds for defining a beneficial owner, varying documentation requirements and distinct reporting standards in each country.

For multinational corporations, such fragmentation complicates compliance efforts while risking the financial and reputational costs of breaking regulations. To accommodate each regulatory environment’s specific demands, firms must develop robust compliance strategies. This often involves significant resources to adapt processes and systems while keeping abreast of regulatory developments.

Multi-layered ownership structures and the use of shell companies, employed to obfuscate the picture of ownership and control, further exacerbate regulatory-compliance issues. Moody’s databases hold information on roughly 525 million companies, and its solution—Shell Company Indicator—is able to signal when a company engages in one of seven outlier behaviours associated with shell companies. Approximately 19 million companies flag at least one of these behaviours, while more than 900,000 flag two or more.

According to Moody’s experts, companies with two or more of these flags may be at a heightened risk of being shell companies, which may warrant further due diligence. Comprehensive monitoring of risks across counterparty networks in real-time is therefore crucial to identifying and investigating entities that could be used for illicit activities.

Due-diligence processes

Thorough due diligence is essential in identifying UBOs and understanding associated risks. The process encompasses initial checks and continuous monitoring to ensure changes in ownership and control are promptly identified and assessed.

Initial checks involve verifying the identities of beneficial owners through information taken from reliable sources, such as government registries and authoritative databases. While the preliminary identification of a UBO is a critical first step in compliance, firms must be prepared to monitor changes in ownership continuously. Without ongoing monitoring, businesses are unable to identify new actors or assess changing risks, such as newly sanctioned entities or newly elected politically exposed persons, and so on.

Firms that fail to conduct adequate UBO checks could face severe financial and reputational damages, as evidenced by a high-profile money-laundering scandal involving a major European bank. Between 2008 and 2016, the bank’s Estonian branch failed to conduct comprehensive checks on high-risk non-resident customers. As a result, an estimated $200 billion in suspicious transactions reached the US financial system through the bank’s correspondent-banking relationships.

The bank’s chief executive officer resigned in 2018 following the scandal and was charged in May 2019 by authorities for neglecting his responsibilities. Although he was later acquitted of criminal charges, the bank’s share value halved within a year of the scandal breaking. In addition to these financial and reputational crises, the bank pleaded guilty to bank-fraud conspiracy and agreed to a $2-billion fine in a case brought by the United States Department of Justice (DOJ).

Best practices for comprehensive checks and monitoring

With the complexity of the financial system and the tightening of regulations in place to stop illicit actors, firms need to adopt robust strategies that include several best practices.

Businesses are particularly prioritising the tools needed to uncover with whom they are doing business. Entity verification, the data-driven process that helps verify and authenticate client credentials, is emerging as a key compliance tool for financial and non-financial firms: A study of 310 compliance professionals from 50 countries found that 9 in 10 respondents rated entity verification as “essential” or “important”.

Using a risk-based approach, businesses can focus resources on high-risk clients and transactions to enhance the efficacy of their due-diligence efforts. By prioritising these areas, companies can allocate resources more efficiently and reduce the potential for financial crime. Furthermore, by implementing this kind of strategy, firms can simultaneously strengthen compliance and enhance customer satisfaction. Ensuring low-risk clients don’t undergo needless risk-assessment checks avoids the frustrations and delays that can have detrimental impacts on the customer experience.

Conducting regular audits of compliance processes is essential to ensuring that systems remain effective and updated. Routinely reviewing and updating compliance frameworks allows businesses to keep pace with regulatory changes and adapt to emerging threats.

Leveraging tools for compliance

Adopting technological solutions is crucial for achieving effective data collection and automation, real-time monitoring and risk analytics. These tools streamline compliance processes, making it easier to identify and verify UBOs while reducing the time and effort required to gather and analyse information.

Moody’s research found that data management is currently a key issue for compliance teams. The firms surveyed cited a myriad of problems, including data silos (51 percent), high costs (46 percent), updating data in a timely manner (44 percent) and data inaccuracy (43 percent). Faced with these challenges, technological solutions allow teams to manage and monitor data better.

Machine learning (ML) and artificial intelligence (AI) algorithms can analyse vast amounts of data, uncovering hidden relationships and potential risks while also helping to identify and match true risks. These technological solutions significantly improve the efficiency and accuracy of compliance. Automated data collection reduces the amount of time and effort needed to gather information from multiple sources, while real-time monitoring more immediately detects changes in ownership or control.

These tools help firms achieve a “golden record”—a single, accurate and complete version of data for a specific entity—that helps decision-making and operational efficiency. Although data management is critical to a successful compliance process, Moody’s research found that only one in ten firms claimed to have a golden record.

Furthermore, only a small minority (14 percent) of respondents in Moody’s survey had fully achieved a “single customer view”—a comprehensive aggregation of all the data relating to a specific customer. By providing a unified view of compliance data and overcoming the problems posed by data fragmentation, firms can make more informed decisions and manage risks more effectively.

Navigating the complexities of UBO compliance

UBO regulations pose significant challenges for businesses. While legislations from bodies such as the Financial Action Task Force and the European Union aim to enhance transparency and crack down on financial crimes, they also create demanding compliance environments, especially for companies operating in multiple jurisdictions.

Thorough due diligence, including initial risk checks and continuous monitoring, is essential in identifying UBOs and mitigating the financial and reputational risks associated with bad actors. Previous scandals have highlighted the severe consequences of inadequate UBO checks, emphasising the need for robust compliance measures.

To ensure effective UBO compliance, businesses need to adopt robust strategies that provide comprehensive approaches to risk management. These may include risk-based approaches, technologies that automate data collection and AI to streamline compliance. The development of artificial intelligence is emerging as a key contributor to a more efficient and accurate risk-management process while helping firms achieve data maturity.

Prioritising UBO compliance is crucial for sound risk management. By adopting a proactive approach, leveraging advanced technologies and adhering to best practices, businesses can successfully navigate regulations and alleviate the financial and reputational dangers posed by illicit actors while helping to maintain the integrity of the global financial system.

 

Related Articles